Limited-time offer₹399₹99 per subjectSave 75%₹100 benefit on bundlesEnds inOffer ends on 8 Nov 2026, 12:00 AM IST
LLB · Semester 4 · Paper K-4004
Criminology and Penology Notes
Chaudhary Charan Singh University
Read Chapter 1 of Criminology and Penology FREE
“Criminology Basics”, the complete chapter, exactly as it appears in the full notes.
Free preview · Chapter 14 min read
Chapter 01
CRIMINOLOGY — DEFINITION, NATURE, SCOPE & METHODS OF STUDY
🔥 PYQ: Definition, Scope, Research Methods — Very Frequent
📋 Previous Year Questions — Chapter 1
4M · SEC-A
Define Criminology according to Sutherland.
Distinguish between Mala in se and Mala prohibita.
What do you understand by the 'Dark Figure of Crime'?
10M · SEC-B
Explain the scope of Criminology and its relationship with Sociology and Psychology.
Distinguish between the Case Study Method and the Life History Method of criminological research.
20M · SEC-C
Discuss the nature, scope, and utility of Criminology. How is it related to Penology and Criminal Law?
Examine the various methods of studying Criminology. Discuss the utility and limitations of the Statistical Method with reference to NCRB reports in India.
Criminology is the scientific, systematic study of the nature, extent, causes, and control of criminal behavior in the individual and in society. The term was coined in 1885 by Italian law professor Raffaele Garofalo (Criminologia).
Edwin Sutherland
Body of knowledge regarding crime as a social phenomenon — covers making laws, breaking laws, and society's reaction to law-breaking.
Walter Reckless
Study of the processing of individuals labeled as violators by formal agents of social control.
M.J. Sethna
Study of human behavior in violation of social norms — covers the criminal mind, environmental factors, and the correctional apparatus.
Nature & Scope
Criminology is an applied social science — not a pure science like chemistry, since its parameters shift with human behavior and legislation, but it uses empirical data, hypothesis-testing, and statistics to study deviance.
SCOPE OF CRIMINOLOGY
Relation with Penology
Criminology diagnoses causes; Penology prescribes treatment/punishment.
Relation with Sociology
Explains how broken social structures & economic disparity generate criminal subcultures.
Relation with Psychology
Studies the criminal mind, trauma, cognitive distortion, personality disorders.
Relation with Criminal Law
Law codifies offences; criminology asks why the law is broken.
Classification of Crime & Deviance
CRIME & DEVIANCE
Legalistic Crime
Statutory violations carrying formal penal sanctions.
Moral/Social Deviance
Violates societal mores without formal penal codes.
Mala in Se
Inherently wrong acts, universally condemned (murder, rape).
Mala Prohibita
Wrong only because statute bans it (traffic rules, tax defaults).
Situational Crime
Spontaneous infraction from immediate opportunity, low detection risk.
Methods of Studying Criminology
Researchers navigate between quantitative methods (measuring volume/trends) and qualitative methods (understanding lived experience and motivation) to study crime empirically.
Positivist Quantitative (Quetelet, Guerry)
- Crime is a regular societal product
- Can be mapped/graphed/predicted by seasonal, spatial, demographic data
Phenomenological Qualitative
- Championed by symbolic interactionists
- Must study meanings offenders assign to their own acts — not just statistics
METHODS OF CRIMINOLOGICAL RESEARCH
Statistical Method
Aggregates public datasets for macro trends; misses "dark figure" of crime.
Case Study Method
Deep-dive into a single subject, institution, or gang.
Life History Method
Tracks an offender's entire life timeline via diaries/interviews.
Comparative Method
Cross-jurisdictional crime-rate study across cultures/legal systems.
Experimental Method
Controlled trials, e.g. recidivism across prison tiers.
Participant Observation
Researcher embeds inside criminal subcultures — ethically risky.
Two Faces of the Same Inquiry
Criminology's Question
"Why did this person commit the crime, and what does it reveal about society?"
Criminal Law's Question
"Did this act satisfy the statutory elements of an offence, and what penalty applies?"
Criminology vs Criminal Law
| Basis | Criminology | Criminal Law |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Behavioral, empirical, descriptive social science | Normative, prescriptive, statutory system |
| Meaning | Studies why people commit crime & society's reaction | Codified rules defining offences & penalties |
| Basis | Focus on the actor, environment, structural causes | Focus strictly on actus reus + mens rea |
| Example | Analyzing if childhood trauma causes adult violence | Prosecuting under Sec 103 BNS / Sec 302 IPC |
| Legal Effect | Non-binding frameworks guiding legislative reform | Directly binding statutory mandates |
| Key Authority | Sutherland / Dr. N.V. Paranjape | Glanville Williams / Ratanlal & Dhirajlal |
Participant Observation vs Statistical Method
| Basis | Participant Observation | Statistical Method |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Qualitative, immersive, exploratory | Quantitative, deductive, mathematical |
| Meaning | Researcher immerses in the subject's natural environment | Consolidates large numeric datasets for analysis |
| Basis | Subjective meaning, motivation, hidden group dynamics | Macro patterns, frequencies, correlations |
| Example | Whyte living among street gangs for Street Corner Society | Analyzing NCRB report to map cybercrime spikes |
| Key Authority | Chicago School (Robert E. Park) | Adolphe Quetelet / NCRB frameworks |
Landmark Cases & Studies
State of Ohio v. Terry (1968) — US Supreme Court
Facts: Officer intercepted suspects pacing suspiciously and found concealed weapons. Held: Legitimized "stop and frisk" on reasonable suspicion — foundation for proactive/situational crime prevention studies.
State of Maharashtra v. Mayer Hans George (1965) — SC of India
Facts: Foreign national carried undeclared gold violating an RBI notification. Held: Absolute liability applies to mala prohibita regulatory offences unless mens rea is implied — shows how regulatory criminology departs from classical intent-based law.
The Polish Peasant in Europe and America (1918-20) — Thomas & Znaniecki
Used life histories, letters, diaries to track displacement, proving social disorganization + rapid immigration break down normative controls; pioneered the life history method.
Stanford Prison Experiment (1971) — Dr. Philip Zimbardo
Students randomly assigned as guards/prisoners escalated into systemic abuse — proved institutional structures dictate abusive behavior more than individual morality; redefined research ethics.
NCRB — "Crime in India" Annual Report
Primary Indian crime-data source, but captures only recorded (police) crimes, not actual victimization rates.
Mala in Se — wrong in itself (murder)
Mala Prohibita — wrong only by statute
Crimen — root term for a charge/crime
In Situ — in the original, natural setting
Falsifiability — capacity of a theory to be disproven
Dark Figure of Crime — unreported crimes never in official data
Exam Tip: Show clear distinction between criminology (behavior) vs criminal law (statutes). Don't just list IPC/BNS sections — bring in sociological/psychological theory, and always highlight the dark figure of crime when discussing research methods.
The whole of Chapter 1, no sign-up needed
What's inside the notes
Chapter by chapter, mapped to the LLB Semester 4 syllabus.
- 01Criminology BasicsFree
- 02Schools of Criminology
- 03Causation of Crime
- 04Specific Crimes
- 05New Dimensions
- 06Penology Concept
- 07Schools & Theories
- 08Capital Punishment
- 09Prison Reform
- 10Alternatives to Imprisonment
- 11Exam Special
01Criminology — Definition, Nature, Scope & Methods of Study
6 topics
- Nature & Scope
- Classification of Crime & Deviance
- Methods of Studying Criminology
- Two Faces of the Same Inquiry
- Criminology vs Criminal Law
- Participant Observation vs Statistical Method
02Schools of Criminology
5 topics
- Evolution of Criminological Thought
- Theory Grid — Key Schools
- Sociological / Chicago School Theories
- Lombroso's Criminal Classification
- Classical School vs Positive School
03Factors in Causation of Crimes
5 topics
- Theory Grid — Causal Factors
- Biological & Psychological Factors
- Socio-Environmental Crime Drivers
- Biological Determinism vs Sociological Causation
- Landmark Studies & Cases
04Specific Crime — Organized, White Collar, Socio-Economic Crime & Juvenile Delinquency
6 topics
- Organized Crime
- White Collar Crime
- Socio-Economic Crime
- Juvenile Delinquency
- White Collar Crime vs Conventional Crime
- Juvenile Delinquent vs Adult Offender
05New Dimensions of Criminology
4 topics
- Theory Grid — New Dimensions
- New Dimensions — Overview Tree
- Feminist Criminology Frameworks
- Critical/Radical vs Traditional/Positivist Criminology
06Penology — Concept, Definition of Punishment, Treatment & Object of Punishment
4 topics
- Historical Forms of Punishment
- Concept of Treatment
- Core Objectives (Object) of Punishment
- Punishment Model vs Treatment Model
07Schools of Penology & Theories of Punishment
5 topics
- Schools of Penology
- Theory Grid — Theories of Punishment
- Sentencing Factors Weighed by Indian Courts
- Modern Sentencing Philosophy in India (IPC/BNS)
- Deterrent Theory vs Reformative Theory
08Capital Punishment
5 topics
- Retentionist vs Abolitionist Arguments
- Procedural Guardrails — Constitutional Validity
- Global Trends
- Abolitionist vs Retentionist Philosophy
- Law Commission — 262nd Report (2015)
09Prison Reform
4 topics
- Prison Reform — Key Milestones
- Prisoner Rights & Reform Areas
- Mulla Committee (1980-83) vs Model Prison Manual (2016)
- Traditional vs Reformed Prison Administration
10Alternatives to Imprisonment — Probation, Parole, Open Prison
7 topics
- Alternatives to Imprisonment — Overview
- Probation — Statutory Framework
- Probation — When Granted vs When Refused
- Types of Parole
- Open Prisons — The Sanganer Model
- Alternatives to Imprisonment — Non-Custodial Tools
- Probation vs Parole
Frequently asked questions
About the Criminology and Penology paper and these notes.
What do the Criminology and Penology notes cover?
The notes cover the definition, scope and methods of criminology, schools of criminology, causes of crime, organised and white collar crime and juvenile delinquency, new dimensions such as feminist and green criminology, then penology: objects of punishment, theories of punishment, capital punishment, prison reform, and probation, parole and open prisons.
What is Lombroso's concept of atavism?
Atavism is the reappearance of primitive ancestral traits. The notes discuss it in the chapter on schools of criminology, along with Lombroso's classification of criminals and the contrast between the Classical and Positive schools.
What is white collar crime according to Sutherland?
The notes take Edwin Sutherland's definition of white collar crime and distinguish it from conventional crime, including the challenges of detecting and prosecuting it in India. Sutherland's theory of differential association is covered in the schools chapter.
What is the rarest of rare doctrine?
The rarest of rare doctrine was laid down in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab. The capital punishment chapter also covers retentionist and abolitionist arguments, mercy petitions under Art. 72 and 161, and the Law Commission's 262nd Report (2015).
What is the difference between probation and parole?
With probation, the offender never enters prison, and it is governed by the Probation of Offenders Act 1958. Parole is for prisoners who have already experienced prison and are moving back into society, under State prison rules and jail manuals. The notes also explain open prisons using the Sanganer open air camp in Jaipur.
What is the exam pattern for Criminology and Penology (K-4004)?
As given in the notes: Section A has 5 compulsory questions of 4 marks, Section B asks 2 of 3 questions of 10 marks, and Section C asks 3 of 5 questions of 20 marks, for a total of 100 marks.
Still have a question? Ask us